AI-illustrated children's books: what to look for and what to avoid
How to tell a carefully made AI-illustrated book from a bad one, covering character consistency, text on pictures, print quality and photo privacy.
AI illustration has made personalised books possible at a price families can actually pay. It has also made a lot of bad books. Here is how to tell the difference before you order.
Does the child look like the same child on every page?
This is the single biggest quality difference. Weak books generate each page independently, so the hero's hair, face and clothes drift from page to page. A child notices this immediately.
Good books lock the character down: a fixed written description of the hero repeated in every illustration request, the same art direction on every page, and reference photos where the family has provided them. Ask to see several inside pages, not just the cover.
Is the text baked into the picture?
Image models are poor at spelling. If a book has words rendered inside the artwork, expect stray letters and broken words, and expect them permanently, because the text cannot be edited afterwards.
Well-made books keep words and pictures separate. The illustration is generated with no text in it at all, the layout reserves a calm area for words, and the text is set in real type on top. That way the words are sharp at print resolution and can be corrected.
Can you read the words over the art?
Words dropped straight onto a busy illustration are a common failure. Look for a soft gradient behind the text, or text placed on a plain paper area, and enough contrast to read at arm's length in a dim bedroom.
Is it actually built for print?
Screen previews hide print problems. A book that will be printed needs bleed beyond the trim line, a safety margin so nothing important gets cut, extra margin near the spine, and a page count that matches what the binding allows. If a service cannot tell you its trim size and bleed, it is probably not printing well.
What happens to your child's photos?
If you upload photos so the illustrations resemble your child, ask what happens to them: where they are stored, whether they are used to train models, and whether you can delete them. A clear answer is a good sign. No answer is a reason to skip the photo step and describe your child in words instead, which works better than most parents expect.
A quick checklist
- The same face on every page
- No text inside the artwork
- Readable words, with a scrim or plain paper behind them
- Stated trim size, bleed and page count
- A clear answer about photos
- The ability to edit any page before you order
Personalised books are keepsakes. It is worth five minutes of checking before one gets printed and put on a shelf for a decade.
Make a book about the thing they love
Free to write and read on screen. Printed hardcovers from $59.99.
Keep reading
- Short bedtime stories: what to do on the nights you have nothing leftA three-minute book that both of you enjoy beats a twenty-minute one nobody finishes. How to make short reading time count, from a parent who often only has short reading time.
- Why your toddler skips pages (and what to do about it)Toddlers do not skip pages because they dislike reading. They skip pages because nothing on that page belongs to them yet. Here is how to fix it.
- How StoryPals works, from a name to a printed bookA walkthrough of making a personalised picture book with StoryPals: the brief, the story, the illustrations, editing every page, and printing.